BaseRT vs PgDog: Detailed Comparison

Overview

BaseRT and PgDog are two open-source tools that serve entirely different purposes. BaseRT is a high-performance LLM runtime optimized for Apple Silicon, designed to run local models with minimal setup. PgDog is a PostgreSQL proxy that combines connection pooling, load balancing, and sharding into a single executable, enabling massive database scalability without application changes.

Feature Comparison

FeatureBaseRTPgDog
Primary FunctionFastest LLM runtime on Apple SiliconPostgreSQL connection pooler, load balancer, sharding proxy
Target PlatformApple Silicon (M-series)Any platform with PostgreSQL
InstallationSingle curl commandHelm, Docker, binary
PerformanceUp to 33% faster decode, 6.4x prefill vs llama.cpp50K+ transactions/s per thread, 2M+ queries/s
Supported Models/DatabasesQwen3, Llama, Gemma, Mistral, Phi-3, Nomic BERTAny PostgreSQL database
Coding Agent IntegrationBuilt-in (pi plugin)Not applicable
Connection PoolingNot applicableReal transaction mode, 100K+ clients
Load BalancingNot applicableRead/write split, health checks, failover
ShardingNot applicableCross-shard transactions, replicated tables, integer PKs
CommunityDiscordOpen source, GitHub, Discord

Pricing

Both BaseRT and PgDog are free and open source. BaseRT has no pricing information, while PgDog's development is backed by a $5.5M seed round, ensuring ongoing improvements.

Pros and Cons

BaseRT

Pros:

  • Fastest LLM runtime on Apple Silicon
  • Simple one-command installation
  • Built-in coding agent support
  • Supports popular open-source models

Cons:

  • Limited to Apple Silicon hardware
  • No database features
  • Smaller ecosystem

PgDog

Pros:

  • Three tools in one (pooling, balancing, sharding)
  • No app changes required
  • High performance and ACID compliance
  • Active development with funding

Cons:

  • Only works with PostgreSQL
  • Requires configuration
  • Overkill for small setups

Verdict

BaseRT is the go-to choice for developers needing the fastest local LLM inference on Apple Silicon, especially for coding agents. PgDog is essential for scaling PostgreSQL databases with connection pooling, load balancing, and sharding. Choose BaseRT for on-device AI, PgDog for database scalability.